Skip to main content

STANFORD MARSHMALLOW AND PRISON EXPERIMENTS

 I misidentified one of my photos yesterday, indicating that I thought they were chicken feet:


A friend sent me to another site which showed this photo as that of weird lemons:


Makes sense because in Chinatown here they would never place chicken feet next to tomatoes.  Sorry, but I did say "I think these are chicken feet."

This friend also sent me this video of the Stanford Prison Experiment, and asked if I was familiar with this study.  My answer is no, but here are the details:
  • In 1971 Stanford psychology professor Philip Zimbardo received a grant from the U.S. Office of Naval Research to conduct a role-play simulation of a prison on campus to determine the psychological effects of prisoners and guards.
  • You can read the details in Wikipedia.
  • Planned for a period of two weeks, Zimbardo terminated the effort after six days because of some outrage and parents' concerns.
  • In short, for decades to follow, this controversial Stanford Prison Experiment was criticized as being deeply flawed and a lie, among other comments, decrying the methodology and ethics.
  • Yet, the experiment did illustrate cognitive dissonance theory and the power of authority.
  • In 2002 there was a BBC Prison Study to examine Zimbardo's themes of tyranny and resistance, and became a documentary series called The Experiment.
    • The findings were very different.
    • There was no evidence of guards conforming to the natural role, and increased resistance of prisoners.
    • A whole slew of subsequent papers also challenged the contention of Zimbardo.
  • Zimbardo, who earned his PhD from Yale, and had already taught at New York University and Columbia before joining the Stanford Faculty in 1968, went on to fashion a successful academic career, including writing The Lucifer Effect and gaining kudos for his work on shyness, anti-bullying and various charitable activities.  
  • He retired in 2003 and remains somewhat active at the age of 88.
Just around the same time, another Stanford psychologist, Walter Mischel, ran  the Stanford Marshmallow Test, suggesting that self-discipline at an early age (4-5) can lead to later success.  I later found a review entitled 40 Years of Stanford Research Found That People With This One quality Are More Likely to Succeed.  I've found that this Power of Delayed Gratification worked for me.  To quote:

The children who were willing to delay gratification and waited to receive the second marshmallow ended up having higher SAT scores, lower levels of substance abuse, lower likelihood of obesity, better responses to stress, better social skills as reported by their parents, and generally better scores in a range of other life measures
.

Does this mean that a child who can't delay gratification will ultimately fail in life?  Well, maybe not.  A 2020 study challenged the original contention.  Yet, that paper came from the Templeton World Charity Foundation, and is linked to a philosophy that is steeped in conservative religion.  Science has been critical of much that the Templeton Prize offers.  But what has religion to do with psychology and success or not?  Philosophers have long wrestled with that question.

Oh well, that is too much thinking for today.  So let me end with life at 15 Craigside, which integrates Ikebana with Chinese New Year, sunsets and flowers, starting with my first water lily of the season, followed by some wonderful arrangements of Irene's students:


Notice in the background a painting titled Good Fortune.


Which leads to our celebration of the Chinese New Year.  There are at least ten ways to spell this, but most in Hawaii say Gung Hei Fat Choy.  However, this literally means May You Be Prosperous and Happy.  The correct way to say Happy Chinese New Year is, in Mandarin, Xin Nian Kuai Le, and in Cantonese, Sun Nin Fai Lok.

On February 1 we had our annual Chinese New Year Lunch.
We had jai, char siu pork and fried rice, hoisin ribs, lup chong steamed fish and rice cake, plus Johnnie Walker Black label and beer.
Then, also celebrating the Chinese New Year, went to Happy Days to pick up a Peking Duck package for a sunset meal on my lanai.

- 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

HONOLULU TO SEATTLE

The story of the day is Hurricane Milton, now a Category 4 at 145 MPH, with a track that has moved further south and the eye projected to make landfall just south of Sarasota.  Good news for Tampa, which is 73 miles north.  Milton will crash into Florida as a Category 4, and is huge, so a lot of problems can still be expected in Tampa Bay with storm surge.  If the eye had crossed into the state just north of Tampa, the damage would have been catastrophic.  Milton is a fast-moving storm, currently at 17 MPH, so as bad as the rainfall will be over Florida, again, a blessing.  The eye will make landfall around 10PM EDT today, and will move into the Atlantic Ocean north of Palm Bay Thursday morning. My first trip to Seattle was in June of 1962 just after I graduated from Stanford University.  Caught a bus. Was called the  Century 21 Exposition .  Also the Seattle World's Fair.  10 million joined me on a six-month run.  My first. These a...

OSAKA EXPO: Day One

Well, the day finally came for us to go to the Osaka Expo.  We were told ahead of time that the long walks would be fearful, giant lines will need to be tolerated just to get into the Expo, with those ocean breezes, it would really be cold, and so forth. Maybe it was pure luck, but we avoided all the above warnings  We had a grand day, and are looking forward to Sunday, our second day at the Expo.  So come along for an enjoyable ride. Our hotel is adjacent to the Tennoji Station, a very large one with several lines.  We upgraded our Suica card and caught the Misosuji red line towards Umeda. Transferred to the Chuo green line at the Hommachi Station.  This Osaka Metro train took us to the Yumeshima Station at the Expo site.   It was a very large mob leaving the train and heading to the entrance. Took only a few minutes to get to the entrance.  This mob was multiplied by at least a factor of  ten of those already waiting to enter.  However...

WHY YOU SHOULD CONVERT TO A JAPANESE HIGH TECH TOILET

Did you know that   Oktoberfest   in Germany is mostly in September?  The very first day of Oktoberfest 2021 was supposed to be today, September 18, extending into October 3.  Well, as in 2020, Oktoberfest was cancelled. So why is it called by that month when it is held mostly in September?  The first celebration in 1810 was in October. Did you also know that Oktoberfest is held only in Munich?  These days seven million drink more than a liter ( about three typical cans ) of beer each, costing around $11.  Except for my wife and I when we followed the crowd to board the S-Bahn to the fairgrounds near Old Town.  It was drizzling a bit.  We bought a large pretzel outside of a typical barn where beer is served.  We did not know that you needed to get this inside the hall.  So no one came to serve us beer.  After a while we decided to have lunch, and the restaurant we settled on only served wine.  Thus, we might have been the ...